Log In   ·   Become A Member

Now Down To Four: Jacob Lusk Sings Goodbye And Haley Reinhart Hits A ’Homer’ On ’American Idol’

Originally Posted: May 05, 2011

  |   8 Comments · Print Article

Judges Steven Tyler, Jennifer Lopez and Randy Jackson during 'Idol' auditions enjoying a laugh when the pressure was not so intense on them or the contestants. (Courtesy Photo: FOX Television)

Southampton - Now down to four, Jacob Lusk is voted off on Thursday. On Wednesday's show, the five remaining "American Idol" contestants hit the stage, and after some sound advice from the judges, guest Sheryl Crow, and 'Idol' contestant mentor Jimmy Iovine, the 'Fabulous Five' performed two songs each spanning "today/contemporary" and "songs from the past/classic."

Host Ryan Seacrest kept Wednesday's program moving briskly even when pointing out Sir Anthony Hopkins among fans in the audience. On Thursday, Lady Antebellum performed, as well as 'Idol' judge Jennifer Lopez, with all the pyrotechnics, sultriness and sexiness this lovely diva is well known for.

On Thursday's program, the magnificent vocals of contestant Jacob Lusk (23) were not enough to keep him in the running. Voted off, he exited blasting those pipes covering the Luther Vandross song "A House is Not A Home." Having been compared to the late Vandross throughout the competition, perhaps it is time for Lusk to finally find his own niche and perform the music he loves, and not be so concerned about pleasing others. This is not a voice to be silenced for any reason, so Lusk should 'Go to church' with the full power of his talent, and enjoy a long career in R&B and Gospel music.

On Wednesday's program, he performed a cover of former 'Idol' winner Jordin Sparks' "No Air." There appeared to be no air in the studio as the judges and audience listened intently in the hopes Lusk would finally use that voice we all know he has - alas, the performance was not so great as judge Randy Jackson stated "I don't think that's the direction for you. Most of it was sharp. It doesn't wear well." An obviously disappointed Lusk did redeem himself with his second performance of Nazareth's "Love Hurts." Indeed, it has hurt to watch this young man with such a gift continually miss the mark week after week.

On Wednesday:

Lauren Alaina (16) - Alaina performed former 'Idol' winner Carrie Underwood's "Flat on the Floor." Judge Steven Tyler issued his usual "It was beautiful." Her second performance of "Unchained Melody," was a beautiful cover of this well loved song; a tender moment as she sang the song for her parents. Lauren, like James may be one of the two to duke it out for the final victory. Alaina took her first trip to the bottom on Thursday's program (with Lusk) and was definitely unhappy about it - don't think she'll be there again if she can help it.

James Durbin (21) - Durbin is most definitely "in it to win it" according to Jackson. His first performance of 30 Seconds to Mars' "Closer to the Edge" kept his fans, the audience and the judges dancing in their seats. He next performed "Without You" by Harry Nilsson, and was so overcome with emotion during rehearsals that he had to take a break. Keeping it together on stage however, Durbin again delivered - according to Jackson "It wasn't perfect. But it was emotionally perfect" which completely summed up what Durbin himself relayed which is "Week after week I leave everything on this stage," and he does and it shows.

Scotty McCreery (17) - McCreery brought that country charm front and center performing Montgomery Gentry's "Gone." Judge Jennifer Lopez enthused "I lost it there for a second. I was so excited," while Tyler offered "I swear to God I saw you dance with the devil." His second performance of Willie Nelson's "Always On My Mind" proved he can match vocals with the best of them, even Crow announced during rehearsals "I can't wait for him to get to Nashville."

And then there was Haley. . .

Haley Reinhart (20) - After having experienced the scorching hot seat week after week, things didn't bode well for Haley with her first performance of an unreleased Lady Gaga tune "You and I." Risky and it didn't pay off with the judges - she was admonished to have chosen a much more well-known song, but then Miss Haley came back for her second performance of The Animals "House of the Rising Sun" - this was a near perfect performance which brought the judges and audience to their feet for the only standing ovation of the evening. Haley hit it big time - Jackson said it was the best performance of the show and he was right - this was one of the best covers of this tune ever.

Down to four...two boys...two girls...one Idol...the competition is now smokin' hot!

Who is my Choice? Who is Your Choice? Who is America's Choice? Post a comment and let us know who you are cheering for.

Read our other 'Idol' articles here: "American Idol: Contestants Feel The Heat", and "American Idol: Bring It To Win It", and "American Idol: This Is Competition" and "American Idol: A Surprising Upset", and "American Idol Rocks On", and "This Is American Idol Season 10".

Stay tuned to Hamptons.com for weekly 'Idol' updates

Eileen Casey spent many years working in the television and music industries in New York City on the "ABC In Concert" weekly series, as well as several prime time network and cable television specials. An award-winning journalist, editor, and artist, and former Editor-in-Chief of Hamptons.com, she enjoys staying warm in Charleston and cool in the Hamptons.

Related Articles:

Guest (Deb K) from Richmond VA says::
Haley has what it takes to win this competition. Her vocal gymnastics are entertaining. She listens to what the judges have to say and adjusts. Her choice of songs is outstanding. She seems to have eliminated a lot of the awkward movements that thwarted her in the beginning. Haley might just be the next American Idol.
May 6, 2011 1:21 pm

Guest (Bobby Fontaine) from Lorton, Va. says::
download free copy of “Steven Tyler’s Secret Past” - http://www.lulu.com/spotlight/BobbyFontaine Everyday this story isn’t told begins new tragedies around the world, that’s how important it is for you to read it. Just released “ Steven Tyler’s Secret Past” is an absolute must read. This true story will keep you on the edge of your seat taking you into the dark world of Steven Tyler, the Mafia bosses who managed his career, and the very strange tactics used to deploy Aerosmith to the top of the world’s rock and roll scene. It’s a story of struggle and hardship, and overcoming great odds against enemies who’d stop at nothing to get their way. A few simple mistakes at the beginning of his career and Steven was in over his head caught between the CIA and his own Sicilian roots.
May 6, 2011 11:17 am

Guest (idontlikehaley) from ny says::
her voice is annoying and she will never sell millions of records . she is a cute girl but if ur voice sounds whiney like u talk then what makes u think someone will pop that cd in their car..real music will never be soley found on american idol its a complete waste of time there is no soul no passion behind these kids no experience nothing that makes me say hmm their music will make me feel what real music is suppose to.
May 6, 2011 8:58 am

Guest (Veronica) from NY says::
Haley should win She has the most talent out of everybody. Her voice is unique, her performances are amazing, and she is never off unlike everybody else in the competition.
May 6, 2011 7:55 am

Guest (ratna) from indonesia says::
i support for james since the very 1st time and still now. He deserve it.
May 5, 2011 10:02 pm

Guest from Sag Harbor says::
Maybe it's time for Jimmy Iovine to go home...hmmm
May 5, 2011 8:16 pm

Guest (akascha) from Trinidad& Tobago says::
James Durbin is definately my choice for the Idol winner this Year. He is absolutely phantastic and will always be a great performer. All the others are good but he is phantastic
May 5, 2011 7:12 pm

Guest (will) from fl says::
haley was great-but she is also going home
May 5, 2011 6:48 pm


Submit Your Comment

Please note, you are not currently logged in. Your comment will be submitted as a guest.
To submit your comment as a member, please click here.
Your Name:
* Comments will be reviewed and posted in a timely fashion
* All fields are required
What color is the sky?
(For spam prevention, thanks)