Log In   ·   Become A Member

’This Is American Idol’ Season 10: America Has Talent!

Originally Posted: March 30, 2011

  |   5 Comments · Print Article

"American Idol" judges: Randy Jackson, Jennifer Lopez, and Steven Tyler, with host Ryan Seacrest. (Courtesy Photo: FOX Television)

Southampton - "This is American Idol" is the battle cry heard around the country and world twice each week (Wednesdays and Thursdays) from one of the hardest working men in show business, Ryan Seacrest, as Season 10 is well underway with some surprises.

This Thursday's episode will have now have two eliminations, since the panel of judges, including Randy Jackson, Steven Tyler, and Jennifer Lopez agreed to use their one and only wild card of the season to hold on to contestant Casey Abrams.

Abrams almost fainted last week as Jackson stopped him after only a few bars into his final chance to announce that "you are staying." The remaining 11 will now all be part of the "American Idol" tour scheduled for this summer.

This season not only had record number try-outs, but also much younger contestants, as the show lowered the qualifying age to 15. With try-outs having taken place across the country - it is now down to these 11 in Los Angeles where the show takes place at CBS Studios (and where the acoustics are questionable).

There are now 11 contestants vying to be the next "American Idol." (Courtesy Photo: FOX Television)

It is 'game on' for these remaining 11 contestants, and the guest talent that has appeared on the show thus far, including Stevie Wonder, (who sang 'Happy Birthday' to Tyler last week), Jennifer Hudson, Sugarland, and Sean 'Puff Daddy' Combs, with his group Diddy-Dirty Money, have set aspirations very high, as well as thrilled their own fans and audience members. The always charming Marc Anthony has appeared a few times, offering up some much needed practical advice on stage presence and the use of ear pieces, and even Hulk Hogan has taken to the stage - much to the awestruck delight of one of the Idol competitors in particular.

Having never watched the show in the last 10 years due to the insufferable ego and occasional cruelty of the now departed Simon Cowell, it is a pleasure to witness the incredible talents of some of America's young songsters, as well as the compassion, professionalism and insightful advice bestowed on them by not only the judges, but Interscope Records President, Jimmy Iovine, and some of the best music producers in the business.

The judges have been gracious and supportive, but it is now up to America to pick their next "American Idol" and it certainly will not be an easy choice.

The Remaining 11 Contestants Include

 • Scotty McCreery: A 16-year-old with a country voice to rival those in Nashville. Charming, sweet and handsome - this young man will have a career in country music with or without 'Idol.'

 • Stefano Longone: An early favorite of Lopez's, he can sing but needs to connect with the audience more. Could be the youngest member of the 'rat pack' generation.

 • Haley Reinhart: She's been on the chopping block twice already and saved - needs to control her voice, but if you let her loose and close your eyes she's got some Janis Joplin in her.

 • Lauren Alaina: An early favorite of Tyler's this young girl can sing, but needs to work on a much more appealing stage presence.

 • Paul McDonald: Can't think of anyone who doesn't love this guy - must be that beautiful smile and white teeth. He can move on stage too. He's been compared to Rod Stewart repeatedly but his voice has greater range and he's a terrific musician as well.

 • Casey Abrams: Good voice and musician, but his stage presence is sloppy and not very attractive. He was headed home and the Idol Gods smiled on him - let's hope he makes good on their faith in him.

 • Thia Megia: This 15-year-old has a beautiful voice to match her style, but she's shy and tentative. If she can show some moxie she may be it - her sheer talent warrants her a place on the Idol stage.

 • Pia Toscano: She may be the one - has style, personality and can sing. Needs to step away from ballads and rock it up a bit.

 • Naima Adedapo: She's also been on the chopping block - obviously has fans but does nothing for me. Has a pleasant voice but her outfits make more of a statement than her talent, and she is trying much too hard to perhaps be something she is not.

 • James Durbin: Love this kid - a young married man with Asperger's Syndrome, and known for the 'tail' of material sticking out of the back of his pants, this young man can sing, rock the house, tone it down, bring it back up and connect with the audience. He has personality plus and is so obviously happy to be there his exuberance is contagious. Not afraid to take risks and does so with a happy smile on his face.

 • Jacob Lusk: When I first heard this young man I turned to my sister and announced - 'it doesn't matter if he wins as Clive Davis (or any other record label owner) is probably sitting in the kid's driveway just waiting to sign him.' Occasionally in a harsh, tough industry you hear a voice that is so good that you know it comes from somewhere other than a studio - that's this young man's voice. One performance was so moving and beautiful, Tyler ran to the stage just to give him a hug. Urged to take some risks away from R&B with song choices, he is proving he can do anything, however, he is so moved by the music that his stage presence is a bit awkward.

Who is my Choice? Who is America's Choice? Who is Your Choice? Stay tuned.

Eileen Casey spent many years working in the television and music industries in New York City on the "ABC In Concert" weekly series, as well as several prime time network and cable television specials. An award-winning journalist, editor, and artist, and former Editor-in-Chief of Hamptons.com, she enjoys staying warm in Charleston and cool in the Hamptons.

Related Articles:

Guest (GT) from Fort Worth says::
Best season ever, Of the top 9 about 7 could have been in the final 2 or won in some years. Jason is like discovering a young Luther Vandrose. Pia may be as good as Whitney, Marriah, or Celine. Scotty will have a long run country career. Lauren may have some success as a country artist. Paul may get a niche audience. Casey, is very talented, but I could see him as life long blues bar singer, not sure if he has a large enough audience that gets how good he is. James would be a great lead man for most rock bands. Haley has some chops too, but again not sure if there will be long term support for her. This is kind of like one of those college football seasons where there are 5 or 6 QBs that will be in the NFL long term. I think Scotty may win, It's a game theory thing, he has the country block and most of the teen girl voting block (probably splitting it with Stephano now). Lusk has Pia have good chances (they have more tallent), and lauren and Casey could pull upsets. Sometimes the vote comes down to protecting the weakest favorite in about week 5. I wish the format was voting off the weakest link, and that scenario would be avoided. If that was the format Casey wouldn't have been on the block nearly so soon. He was because Naima was getting sympathy vote.
Apr 4, 2011 6:39 pm

Guest (JoAnn Sheekey) from England says::
This is the best year of AI. The judges are the best. They are there to help the contestants rather than to take away from them with their egos and petty squabbles. I love Jennifer, Steven and Randy. They are there to help rahter than to distract from the event. These are the best judges yet. Don't miss Simon. at all.
Apr 1, 2011 8:19 pm

Guest from hi says::
Thia is the best!!!!!
Mar 30, 2011 8:02 pm

Guest from Sag Harbor says::
This season is so much better than previous ones..I did not enjoy seeing hopefuls being humiliated and almost made to cry. It is a much more positive Idol with the new judges..and I love love Steven Tyler :-)
Mar 30, 2011 4:19 pm

Guest (music lover) from Apex, NC says::
Think Casey Abrams has shown a multitude of talents. He's not only a singer but can certainly play several musical instruments as well as make some awesome city street music. James Durbin can rock the house. I agree with the previous post. Jacob Lusk has an incredible voice. Just needs to control it unless he's lookin' for Broadway. Think he'll get signed w/someone either way. Pia has increadible singing talent but get the impression she's from wealth and can get there on her own. Thia Megia has a beautiful voice, just needs to mature to really be ready to show the world what she can do. A smart producer would grab her while he/she can mold her the way she's needed. Naima Adedapo has incredible stage presence, beautiful eyes, no fear but not sure she's really got the voice to take it all the way. Haley Reinhart has got an awesome voice. Would love to hear her sing a Melissa Ethridge tune, Janice Joplin's Bobby McGee, or a Stevie nicks song. I also think she'd have more confidence on stage if she wore a pair of flats. Think she looks uneasy about falling off her heels. Lauren and Scotty have talent but I am not too fond of Country music so I don't think I'd have an unbiased or a fair opinion. Stefano really surprised me. I didn't think he had as much talent as he does. I just think he needs to have more fun with it. He appears too worried about doing each song "big enough" rather than just "going with it." Which brings me back to Casey and James. I love that they both seem to just "get into" what they are singing and playing. My personal favorites are; Casey, James and Haley. I'd have a really hard time picking between them. Overall I think they all ROCK. Wish I had a smidge of their talents. Want to thank them for some enjoyable TV
Mar 30, 2011 4:08 pm


Submit Your Comment

Please note, you are not currently logged in. Your comment will be submitted as a guest.
To submit your comment as a member, please click here.
Your Name:
* Comments will be reviewed and posted in a timely fashion
* All fields are required
What color is a firetruck?
(For spam prevention, thanks)