Log In   ·   Become A Member

Anti-Biased Activists Call For Dismissal Of Editor Over Controversial Columns

Originally Posted: February 12, 2008

Peter Neely

  |   5 Comments · Print Article

Following the strictly serious community forum called to address two controversial "Low Tidings" columns published in The Independent, area activists shared a convivial moment Friday evening. Photos by Peter Neely

Bridgehampton - Community groups came out in force to participate in a open forum held at the Hayground School Friday night, Feb. 8, to air their opinions in an open discussion regarding two controversial columns written by Rick Murphy, editor of The Independent. The meeting was attended by approximately 40 representatives of community groups reacting to the tone of the columns which attempted parody of the Democratic candidates for president, Senators Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton.

The public forum quickly transformed into a venue where any and all points of view concerning writing to The Independent publisher Jerry Della Femina were entertained. The "Low Tidings" columns were published in successive weeks in January, hitting a politically incorrect nerve among area residents and community activists who perceived the pieces to be offensive, depicting an insensitivity to race, gender, and sexual preference.

Lucius Ware, President of the NAACP's Eastern Long Island branch, an
organizer of the forum, opened the dialogue with a request that the press
refrain from taking photos in order to encourage camera shy attendees to
feel free to speak.

Lucius Ware, chapter head of the Eastern Long Island chapter of the NAACP, opened the meeting to set ground rules for the discussion, limiting speakers to a two minute platform. Emphasizing the intention of the forum, Ware cautioned, "This is not a media event, we want people who might not normally have the opportunity to speak out to not have their picture taken or to be recorded while speaking. This is a thinking process."

Community organizations in attendance included the Southampton, Riverhead, and East Hampton Anti-Bias Task Force groups, representatives of the Shinnecock Indian Nation and the East End Gay Organization (EEGO), in addition to the NAACP local chapter.

Following the precautions evident in the initial round of comments, subsequent speakers successively shed apprehensions in regards to making public their opinions as many stood to read from notes presenting concise statements to shed light on the nuances of the socio-politically charged columns in question.

Crossed The Line
"These articles have caused a lot of hurt," Ken Allen, co-chair of the East End Gay Organization (EEGO), expressed to the crowd. "They crossed the line. We want to start a healing process on this. Articles like this do not have a place in a traditional newspaper."

East Hampton Town Supervisor William McGintee spoke with Randy King,
Chair of the Shinnecock Nation, following the open forum.

Echoing these sentiments, East Hampton Planning Board member Robert Schaeffer went on record, calling the columns, "regrettable, tasteless and vulgar. These are nothing more than tawdry, discourteous and racist."

One local African-American resident offered that for the first time in her 80-plus years the controversial "Low Tidings" columns inspired her to write a letter to the editor for the first time. "In my letter I asked for Mr. Murphy's resignation," she asserted. Other members of the crowd emphasized that the actual columns were not as offensive as they found Murphy's response to the backlash. One community member called Murphy "unapologetic," adding, "it does not sound like he is sorry."

Baldwin Chimes In
Actor Alec Baldwin, who was also in attendance, has engaged in a heated written exchange published in the letters section of The Independent with publisher Della Femina. Seated across from Della Femina and East Hampton Town Supervisor William McGintee, Baldwin was second in line to speak.

"Some of the things I heard recently advocated boycotting the newspaper," Baldwin stated. "I have read letters suggesting the community boycott [Jerry Della Femina's] restaurant. I think that's a mistake, I don't think people who work at the restaurant and the newspaper should suffer as a result of this."

Following the often heated dialogue, community members in attendance discussed
the sentiments of the meeting. Lisa Votino-Tarrant, of the Southampton Anti-Bias
Task Force stands in the foreground and former Democratic candidate for Southampton
Town supervisor Jim Henry is standing in the background.

Additional statements by the community appeared to tap into a general sentiment that encouraged Della Femina to release the editor from his duties, emphasizing that it would send a clear message in regards to the publisher's disapproval while affecting as few individuals as possible in the organization.

In response to the public comments, Della Femina offered a full page and/or open column for interested community groups seeking to draw attention to sensitive issues in the community. "The pages will not be edited or even seen by Rick Murphy. It is your page as a group. You have a page in my newspaper," he explained, adding, in terms of the two pieces in question, "Mr. Murphy is on a very short leash. This was his last chance, and from now on I will see everything he writes." Della Femina also stated that the "Low Tidings" column has been suspended from publication.

Addressing the issue later in the discussion as an overwhelming consensus continued to be forming calling for the editor's dismissal, Della Femina added, "I find it hard to fire people, but I do not fire people when they make their first mistake. I fire them the second time."

On the heels of Della Femina's comment a stir rumbled through the audience and two representatives from the Shinnecock Nation rose to bring attention to what they deemed Murphy's first mistake. Members of the Shinnecock Nation have reportedly picketed The Independent offices in the past, following previous remarks that also appeared in the "Low Tidings" column, which were perceived by the group to be demeaning and offensive.

Lance Gumbs, trustee of the Shinnecock Indian
Nation, reported an earlier instance where the
newspaper's reference to the Shinnecock Nation
caused controversy.

Lance Gumbs, former chair of the tribe who is currently a tribal trustee,
clarified that initial good faith efforts brought them in contact with the newspaper, which was unappreciated when followed by, in his estimation, an offensive column. Gumbs explained, "I called The Independent first to discuss the plight and poverty of our tribe. According to the census, sixty percent of our people live below the poverty line. What came out in the paper following our meeting was absolutely deplorable. This has been an ongoing pattern."

Randy King, Chair of the Shinnecock Nation, concurred, adding "Two years ago I told Jerry, I said, I like your column and your paper -- but your articles and Mr. Murphy's have started to take a tone - you attacked our nation, calling us a 'dog and pony show.' I've been waiting for that apology."

One local attorney did stand to support Della Femina, expressing his opinion that the publisher "has taken some good first steps here. I don't believe that [Murphy] meant to be offensive. [Della Femina] can't control every editorialist, but he can sanction them."

Lucius Ware, who sought to keep the exchange in perspective, reminded those in attendance that there is still work to be done in terms of racial sensitivity and awareness throughout the community.

"We sit here on Eastern Long Island where there are more noose sightings than any other state in the nation. Right now, the New York State legislature is currently revising its hate crime laws, with a specific section concerning nooses." Further, he added that as recently as 1929, there was a Ku Klux Klan (KKK) slate running for office in Sag Harbor, saying, "apparently some of the robes and ropes are still in the closet."

Jim Henry, the recently defeated Democratic contender for Southampton Town Supervisor, addressed the crowd in the capacity as a civil rights lawyer, stating, "The climate of race and bigotry here [is something] we have to acknowledge and deal with." Calling the columns "propaganda," he added that they are "nodding at the attitude underlying this violence." He added he understood the columns to be part of a recurrent pattern of irresponsible behavior on the part of the editor.

"It would be so easy for me to fire Rick," Della Femina said. "My wife would be happy, my son-in-law and daughter would be happy, but I can't do that. There will be a new Independent newspaper, you can be assured of that," he concluded.

Shinnecock Nation Tribal Chair Gumbs responded, asserting, "There is nothing wrong with the paper. There is something wrong with the editor."

No further actions regarding the matter were discussed by the community members in attendance.

Related Articles:

Guest (kyle) from lakewood, ca says::
I noticed this article never mentioned what the supposedly "offensive" columns said, but does state that they were parody (meaning humorous and not serious) of last year's presidential candidates. I am sure it is hard for these poor exploited Shinnecock people to do something about their 60% poverty level knowing that somebody at the Independent might be making fun of somebody else, or that as "recently" as 80 years ago some guy in the Klan ran for office somewhere else.
Dec 18, 2009 4:08 pm

Guest (R. Larsen Matthews) from NYC says::
Years ago (like 10 years ago) I was planning a fund raising event in East Hampton and they wrote a feature piece on my event and published photos. On top that, I love the features and columns of Heather Buchanan, Kitty Merrill and the late Sherrill Foster. This Rick Murphy seems like a real bad apple, but the people who work at The Independent are genuine and will help a good cause in any way they can.
Feb 13, 2008 9:57 pm

Guest (Lisa Votino-Tarrant) from Hampton Bays, NY says::
For those that read this article and want to get involved, please feel free to contact me at LMVotino@optonline.net. I was one of the organizers of Friday's Community Forum and Peter did a great job covering it.
Feb 13, 2008 2:01 pm

Guest (Kathy) from Philadelphia says::
Mr. Murphy should step down, look forward, and move out with his racist out of the closet thinking. Mr. Della Femina who are you fooling, hiding behind Mr. Murphy? Is this your ill feelings coming out through this ill individual?
Feb 13, 2008 12:00 am

Guest (L. Youngblood) from Southampton, NY says::
I respectfully disagree with Mr. Baldwin. I believe that all of Mr. Della Feminaís holdings should be boycotted; as well as, all of the companies and organization who advertise in The Independent. Money is power; the way to get real change is to reallocate power. Mr. Murphy nor Mr. Della Femina are blameless in this situation and their ďAwe shucks, I am so sorry. Ricky is a bad, bad boyĒ attitude is insulting. Anyone who accesses this publication on a regular basis knows this is not an isolated incident. By continuing to support The Independent we, as a community, are apathetically condoning their ideas. I read in an article where Mr. Della Femina was being asked about previous questionable content and his response was, and I paraphrase, ĎThe publication is free if you donít want to read what I have to say, donít pick it up.í As a community we should take that one step further. Donít pick it up, donít advertise in it, donít dine in his restaurant, and donít use his advertising agency. Tell your friends, your family, and your neighbors. In time, the power will shift from the narrow minded, hurtful attitudes expressed in The Independent to the dominant and hopeful attitudes that are obviously preferred by our community. We are not guaranteed to change the way people think or feel, but we can guarantee that the attitudes that we as a community believe to be toxic and counterproductive are not instituted.
Feb 13, 2008 12:00 am


Submit Your Comment

Please note, you are not currently logged in. Your comment will be submitted as a guest.
To submit your comment as a member, please click here.
Your Name:
* Comments will be reviewed and posted in a timely fashion
* All fields are required
What color is a firetruck?
(For spam prevention, thanks)