Log In   ·   Become A Member

Can A Real Estate Broker Be Entitled To A Commission If The Client Buys A Different Property From The One He Shows The Buyer?

John A. Viteritti

While in the past, it has been most common for real estate brokers to represent sellers, this is changing. (Photo: Nicole Barylski)

In our last article, we drew on a court ruling that demonstrated how a seller/client may be obligated to pay a broker's commission absent a written listing agreement, (employment contract), with the seller. In this article, we examine whether a broker who represents a buyer may be entitled to a commission even if the buyer buys a different property than the one shown to them by the broker, again, absent a written employment contract between the broker and buyer. For the answer, we look to the Manhattan case, SPRE Realty, Ltd. V. Dienst, May 20, 2014, Appellate Division, Supreme Court. The lower court ruling in favor of the broker took place on October 1, 2013.

The Appeals Court stated the following: "In this appeal, we must determine whether the plaintiff broker has alleged facts sufficient to establish its entitlement to a commission on the sale of real estate, where it expended significant effort locating an apartment for buyers who abandoned the transaction and purchased another apartment in the same building 18 months later." It further stated: "In addition, we take this opportunity to clarify the standard by which a broker may be found to have been the 'procuring cause' of a real estate transaction."

The court determined that the buyers retained the broker to help them purchase a luxury residence in Manhattan. It further determined that even though the parties did not have a written agreement, they did have an understanding that the broker would receive a commission after finding them a residence that met their expectations. The broker showed the buyers several residences in Manhattan over the next 18 months, and around October 2007, showed them a condominium unit under construction. After the buyers expressed an interest in the unit, the broker brought them to meet with the developer, and the broker negotiated terms of the purchase on the buyer's behalf. The agreement was for two units for $11.5 million. A contract exchanged between the two attorneys representing the seller and buyer contained the same terms as negotiated by the broker. The broker searched for architects who could meet the buyers' design requirements and subsequently arranged a meeting with an architect and the developer at the buyers' summer home in Sag Harbor. In late August 2008, the buyers changed their minds and said they were no longer in the market for a new home. A few months later, according to the court, the broker contacted the buyers to inquire if they had any renewed interest in purchasing a home but did not receive a response. The court further stated that the broker continued "in good faith" to assist the buyers in their search for a commercial property to be used as an antique store. They repeatedly confirmed they were no longer seeking to purchase a residence and had no interest in the building where the unit they originally agreed to purchase was located. Despite these assurances, in February 2010, they purchased a different pair of units in the same building. The broker filed a lawsuit for a commission in May 2013 for breach of an implied contract and unjust enrichment on the part of the buyers. The buyers countered that they never signed a contract of sale for the first units, and the broker was not involved in the purchase of the units they did buy.

The court disagreed. It stated, in part: "A broker may be entitled to a commission where the buyer authorizes the broker to submit an offer to the seller but subsequently fails to execute or arbitrarily refuses to enter into a contract of sale." The court also said: "Even if SPRE [the broker] is unable to prove that it was the procuring cause, it may be able to prove that the defendants [buyers] terminated its activities in bad faith and as a mere device to escape the payment of the commission." The court also gave credit to the broker's contention that the units the buyers ultimately purchased were "substantially identical" to the units that the broker had procured for them.

On May 20, 2014, the Appellate Court unanimously upheld the lower court's decision of the October 1, 2013 ruling in favor of the broker with costs.

While in the past, it has been most common for real estate brokers to represent sellers, this is changing. It has now become, even in the Hamptons real estate market, more common for brokers to represent buyers.

John is a St. John's University graduate, licensed Real Estate broker, lecturer, teaches real estate license classes at LIU, NYU, and Cook Maran Real Estate School, and is a well-respected consultant to the real estate industry. www.johnaviteritti.com

Related Articles:

Be the first to comment on this article. (Just fill out the form below)

Submit Your Comment

Please note, you are not currently logged in. Your comment will be submitted as a guest.
To submit your comment as a member, please click here.
Your Name:
* Comments will be reviewed and posted in a timely fashion
* All fields are required
What color is a banana?
(For spam prevention, thanks)
Gary R. DePersia, Corcoran Real Estate
With over $2 billion in transactions on the East End and since 1995, Gary DePersia is consistently ranked among the top producers in the Hamptons. A year-on-year member of The Corcoran Group President’s Council, he has qualified as a national list maker since 2007. In 2008 he was Corcoran's top broker on the East End by sales volume and rental units; and ranked as the nation’s 4th top broker. In the 2017 REAL Trends & The Wall Street Journal list of America’s top real estate professionals, he was designated #26 nationally, #4 in the Hamptons and #3 at Corcoran overall by volume with nearly $200 million of transactions for the past year. His office operates with four licensed assistants allowing him to build a business stretching from Southampton to Montauk and Sagaponack to Shelter Island. gdp@corcoran.com

Bridgehampton National Bank
For over 100 years Bridgehampton National Bank has been the East End's hometown bank. Many success stories...one bank, BNB!

Advertise on Hamptons.com - Have your business be seen by over 2 million viewers including NEW searches
Hamptons.com- Our exclusive online magazine has 2.6 million Page Views YTD for 2015. Contact us to join our elite group of clients that benefit from having a presence on the Hamptons award winning publication www.Hamptons.com

Hamptons Carpet One Floor & Home
We pay less,and so do you.With over 1,000 stores in our buying group, we can get the lowest prices from the best flooring manufacturers — and pass the savings on to you.Visit our other locations: Hamptons Carpet One Floor & Home, 675 North Sea Road,Southampton, NY 11968

Southampton Masonry-Visiting the Southampton or the Wainscott locations is an exciting experience.
Southampton Masonry has been serving Long Island's masonry and tile needs since 1975. Delivering quality products from Manhattan to Montauk for over three decades. The company's continued success is due primarily to their number one priority: customer satisfaction, with a promise of prompt and courteous service from the professional, knowledgeable staff. Southampton Masonry has the largest inventory on the east end. As direct importers they can offer a large variety of the finest quality products at the most competitive pricing for both your interior and exterior projects.

CP Complete- Landscape Design & Construction
Paul Guillo And Chris Hall Two Of The Most Respected Names In The Community Together, they are partners in CP Complete. They bring their years of experience and integrity to creating and renovating luxury backyards.

CP Complete- Landscape Design & Construction
Paul Guillo And Chris Hall Two Of The Most Respected Names In The Community Together, they are partners in CP Complete. They bring their years of experience and integrity to creating and renovating luxury backyards.

D+J Concepts is known for a high-end cutting edge approach to design.
D+J Concepts is known for a high-end cutting edge approach to design with a balance between functionality and imagination. We skillfully and tastefully transform ordinary spaces into classic modern styles, which are understated, and luxe. We’re known for our modern transitional style incorporating antiques and modern elements for an unexpected edge.