Sag Harbor - There are many many components that make a summer complete, including endless days on the beach, hitting the waves out on a boat, and of course sinking your teeth into an good old fashioned hamburger. There is no better place to do that in the Hamptons than at Bay Burger in Sag Harbor, with its delicious home cooked burgers, homemade ice cream, and specialty sandwiches.

The Sign Out Front: Good Eats Ahead (Christopher Beninati)

Walking into Bay Burger it was clear that the warm and cozy décor just makes you feel like summer year round, with its color tones of blue and white, and the air perfumed with the smells of fresh ground meat, and warm buttery rolls, as well as the chatter of hungry patrons. There are many seats inside and even some outdoor seating but they go fast as everyone must form a line to place their order. Obviously, it is all about the burgers here with many options to make yrou burger to your liking such as various cheeses, bacon, onions, tomato, mayo, and much more.

The best option for me was a hamburger topped with cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo on a homemade bun. The first bite was something revolutionary as the components of each fresh ingredient blended together so well that it truly morphed itself into the perfect burger. Most problems that are imposed on hamburgers are the bun but not this one; the homemade bun is still warm and buttery, and is the perfect pal for the Grade A fresh patty of beef. The cheese was draped over the patty to add extra creaminess and along with the mayo blended deliciously. The lettuce and tomato made for a nice cold crunch adding perfect balance to the meal.

On the side were perfectly fried tots, which were golden brown and added the right amount of crunch to the meal, get them loaded with crumbled bacon and cheese for an extra $2.50. Although the burger is the star of the show here there are many great menu items including a buffalo chicken sandwich that is the right amount of heat and high quality with its all white meat chicken breast. They also have a classic fish sandwich with fresh cod and homemade tarter sauce, a falafel with tahini sauce and even a veggie burger with black beans and roasted vegetables. The menu also boosts classics such as grilled cheese, a scrumptious looking BLT and an all-beef kosher hotdog.


To wash it all down Bay Burger has great beers on tap and from the bottle, along with local wines, but do not overlook their homemade shakes with many great flavors that change daily. Owners Joe and Liza Trembley have started their own brand "Joe and Liza's Ultra Premium Ice Cream" and create many great flavors including classics and new concoctions to be enjoyed as a milkshake and or after dinner.

On Thursday nights they host Music Night from 7 p.m. to 9 p.m supporting many local musicians, and can hold a private event for up to 20 guests.

Bay Burger is a burger-maniac's dream come true because the craft of making a truly great burger is mastered here. The friendly staff and location make Bay Burger a perfect place to bring the family or a first date. The dedication and hard work of Joe and Liza and their entire team has made Bay Burger into a Hamptons classic that can not be topped.

Bay Burger is located at 1742 Bridgehampton/Sag Harbor Turnpike in Sag Harbor, 631-899-3915.